Notices:
IMPORTANT NOTICE TO ALL TAXPAYERS FILING A PETITION
The
2011 Legislature enacted Chapter 2011-181, Laws of Florida,
effective July 1, 2011. These laws shall apply to petitions filed
with Value Adjustment Boards on or after July 1, 2011. For
additional information pertaining to Sections 1, 2 and 3, please
review Bulletin PTO 11-07 shown below.
Bulletin PTO 11-7
Value Adjustment Board of Charlotte County
Notice of Meeting
2011 VAB
Final Adoption Hearing
PLEASE BE ADVISED
that the 2011 Charlotte County Value Adjustment Board will meet on
the 29th day of June, 2012, at 9:00 AM, in Murdock at the
Charlotte County Administration Complex, Commission Chambers, Room
119, 18500 Murdock Circle, Port Charlotte, Florida, to act upon
the recommendations of the appointed Special Magistrates who have
conducted hearings and taken testimony in cases presented to them
and to discuss other related issues at the suggestion or request
of the Chairman or members prior to or during the meeting. The
recommendations will be adopted by the Board pursuant to Section
194.035 (1) Florida Statutes.
If a person
decides to appeal a decision made by the Charlotte County Value
Adjustment Board with respect to any matter considered at this
meeting, a record of the proceeding will be needed for such
purpose, and such person will need to ensure that a verbatim
record of the proceeding is made, to include the testimony and
evidence upon which any such appeal is to be based.
If you have a
disability that will require special assistance or accommodations
for your attendance at the meeting, please call the Value
Adjustment Board Clerk at (941) 743-1403.
This meeting
will be open to the public.
File Petitions or Check Petition Status
2011 Petitions: You can file your
petition online and pay by Visa or MasterCard credit card. To
file in person or by mail see "Where to
File" below.
2011 VAB Members
and Special Magistrates
The 2011 Value Adjustment Board (VAB)
members are:
Charlotte County Commissioner Bob Starr
Charlotte County Commissioner Robert
Skidmore Board of
County Commission Citizen Representative Eric Loche
School Board Member Barbara Rendell
School Board Citizen Representative Rodney
Taylor
The VAB, at its September 22, 2011 organizational meeting:
(1) elected Commissioner Robert Skidmore as chair and Rodney
Taylor as vice chair. (2) selected Ellen T. Chadwell, PL, Esq.,
as the primary attorney magistrate (hearing appeals concerning
denials of exemptions and classifications) and Herbert E.
Langford, Jr., P.A., Esq., as the alternate attorney magistrate.
(3) selected Gerald A. Lagace, ASA, as the appraiser to
hear tangible property valuation appeals.
(4) selected Dennis J. Black, MRICS, IFAC, ASA, Certified
General Appraiser, as the primary appraiser magistrate, (hearing
appeals related to both commercial and residential property) and
Raymond H. Krasinski, MBA,GAA,RAA,IFA,ASA, Certified General
Appraiser, as alternate appraiser magistrate (hearing appeals
related to both commercial and residential property.
Neither the petitioner, his agent or attorney, or the Property
Appraiser, should communicate with a VAB member or Special
Magistrate concerning pending petitions other than “on the record”
during a scheduled hearing.
Inappropriate contact may result in the recusal of the VAB
member or the Special Magistrate, or other measures.
All questions and concerns should be directed to VAB clerk
staff.
If a person decides to
appeal a decision made by the Charlotte County Value Adjustment
Board with respect to any matter considered at any meeting, a
record of the proceeding will be needed for such purpose, and such
person will need to ensure that a verbatim record of the
proceeding is made, to include the testimony and evidence upon
which any such appeal is to be based.
If you have a disability
that requires special assistance or accommodations for your
attendance at any meeting, please call the Value Adjustment Board
Clerk at (941) 743-1403.
All VAB meetings are open to the
public.
For more information,
please contact the Charlotte County VAB Clerk, 4th Floor, Murdock
Administration Complex, 18500 Murdock Circle, Room 416, Port
Charlotte, Florida.
Call: 941-743-1403
BACK TO TABLE OF CONTENTS
Florida Administrative Code Rules and Forms
The
following rules, providing uniform policies and procedures for value
adjustment boards statewide, became effective
Tuesday, March 30, 2010:
- Rule
Chapter 12D-9 and accompanying forms
- A
partial repeal of the rules in Rule Chapter 12D-10
- Amendments to Rule 12D-16.002, F.A.C.
Now that they are effective, these rules have become law and value
adjustment boards, clerks, property appraisers, and tax collectors
are required to follow the rules, as stated in section
Fla Stat 195.027 (1) and Fla Stat 194.011(5)(b). The new rules supersede any
local rules or prior Department of Revenue rules on the subject.
The rules described above
as well as the three sets of documents described below are available
on the Department’s website at the following web address:
http://dor.myflorida.com/dor/property/vab/.
-
The 2010 Uniform Policies and Procedures Manual for value adjustment boards,
which is composed of the following items:
-
The rights of taxpayers as provided in Florida Statutes and the recently
adopted rules;
-
The recently adopted rules of procedure for value adjustment board
proceedings;
-
Recently adopted forms for value adjustment boards;
-
Florida Statutes regarding value adjustment board procedures; and
-
A notice regarding the use of case law.
Accompanying the Uniform Policies and Procedures Manual are two sets of
documents titled:
-
“Other Legal Resources Including Statutory Criteria”, and
-
“Reference Materials Including Guidelines”.
Each of these three sets of documents contains an introduction that provides
orientation on the authority, content, and use of that respective set
General
Information
A taxpayer may file a petition with the VAB for the following reasons:
- The taxpayer objects to the Property Appraiser's
value assessment of the taxpayer's real or personal property.
- The taxpayer's application for any of the following
exemptions or special use classifications is denied:
- homestead exemption;
- any other tax exemption as provided by Fla. Stat. § 196;
or
- any special use classification as provided by
Fla. Stat. § 193.
- Fla. Stat. § 194.011(6)
(a),
gives a taxpayer an opportunity to file a petition appealing "...the amount
of the assessment limitation difference for which the taxpayer qualifies as
stated by the property appraiser in the county where the previous homestead
property was located...." The taxpayer can also appeal the decision of the
property appraiser in that county if the property appraiser "has not stated
that the taxpayer qualifies to transfer any assessment limitation
difference...." These petitions are filed with the value adjustment board in
the county where the new homestead property is located.
Fla. Stat. § 194.011(6)
directs the Value Adjustment Board in that county to immediately send a
notice of appeal to the Value Adjustment Board in the county where the
previous homestead was located, and that board shall reconvene even if it
has already adjourned.
The Property Appraiser's Office is often able to resolve
objections through an informal conference with the taxpayer. These informal
discussions take place in the Property Appraiser's Office located at 18500
Murdock Circle, Room 328, Port Charlotte, FL 33948. The
telephone numbers are:
- Exemptions & Portability
941-743-1593.
- Classified Value 941-743-1483
- Real Property 941-743-1498
- Tangible Personal Property 941-743-1476
Persons wishing to attempt to resolve matters with the
Property Appraiser's Office prior to a hearing should contact the office to
schedule a meeting. It has been the
experience of the
Charlotte
County Property
Appraiser’s Office that most objections are settled informally, eliminating the
need for a formal hearing before the Value Adjustment Board.
Petitions to the Charlotte County VAB will be heard by
impartial special magistrates in a quasi-judicial forum. Petitions are accepted at the Official Records Division,
Clerk of the Circuit Court, 350 E. Marion Avenue, Punta Gorda, FL 33950 and in person and by mail at 18500 Murdock Circle,
Room 416, Port Charlotte, FL 33948.
Fla. Stat. § 194.032(1)(c)(2)
requires that the petitioner be notified of his/her scheduled hearing date no
later than 25 calendar days prior. Upon receipt of that notification, the
petitioner has the right to reschedule one single time by submitting a written
request to the VAB clerk no later than 5 calendar days prior to the date of the
originally scheduled hearing
(click here
to download the reschedule request form).
BACK TO TABLE OF CONTENTS
Deadlines
to file petitions
All petitions must be filed before the deadlines
established by law. The filing date is the date on which the petition is
actually received by the VAB. It is not the date when the petition
is deposited
in the US mail or with other delivery services. Filing deadlines are as follows:
-
Assessment petitions:
TRIMS are mailed by the Property
Appraiser in August; petitions shall be filed within 25 days
following. That date will
be printed on the TRIM notice.
-
Appeals of denials of homestead or other tax exemptions and
special use classifications: Denials for agricultural and
homestead exemptions are mailed in June;
Fla.
Stat. 194.011 (2) (d) establishes the deadline to the
file denial appeals as “any time during the taxable year on or
before the 30th day following the mailing of the notice” mailed
by the Property Appraiser.
BACK TO TABLE OF CONTENTS
Non-Refundable
Filing Fees
-
There is a $15 filing fee for each separate parcel submitted for
appeal to the Value Adjustment Board. Each separate parcel will
require a separate petition form. However, the filing fee can be
paid with one check, money order or cash (U.S.
funds only).
-
The fee for the first contiguous (adjoining) or multiple parcel
is $15; subsequent parcels are $5 each. A single joint petition
may be filed by a condominium association, cooperative
association, homeowners association or timeshare/interval
ownership type entity with the approval of its Board of
Directors or Administration. Form DR-486MU should be completed
and attached to the petition form in these situations.
NOTE: The petitioner must obtain approval form and
signature of Property Appraiser staff prior to filing a joint
assessment petition.
-
There is no filing fee for denial of homestead or homestead tax
deferral appeals, provided that denial is not because of a
late-filed application.
According to
Fla. Stat. § 194.013(3),
the filing fee must be paid when the VAB petition is filed or the
petition will be considered invalid and rejected. Checks or money orders (U.S. funds only)
should be made payable to the Board of County Commissioners (BOCC).
The VAB shall waive the filing fee
with respect to a petition filed by a taxpayer who demonstrates at the time of
filing, by an appropriate certificate or other documentation issued by the
Department of Children and Family Services and submitted with the petition, that
the petitioner is then an eligible recipient of temporary assistance under
Fla. Stat. § 414 and
Fla. Stat. § 194.013(3).
BACK TO TABLE OF CONTENTS
Petition
Contents and Instructions
Please be sure the petition includes the
following information:
-
Addresses and telephone numbers of persons whose privacy is
protected by the public records law as specified in
Fla. Stat. § 119.071(4) will be redacted if
the petitioner notifies the VAB Deputy Clerk of that right.
-
Parcel Number
-
Owner of Record
-
Signatures of the owner or designated agent, as appropriate
-
Time limit estimate
-
Dates not available for hearing
-
Hard copies of exhibits or attachments to petitions will not be
returned and must be identified with the property's parcel
number and owner of record. Subsequent evidence exchange, if
any, is handled directly with the Property Appraiser. An
exception is made if the petitioner does not plan to be present
at the hearing. In those instances only, the petitioner needs to
submit evidence to the Clerk. (Refer to "Hearing
Information/Procedures" below for additional information
regarding evidence exchange.)
-
Petitioners must deliver or mail
Form DR-486MU
to the Property Appraiser’s
Office for a determination that parcels are contiguous
undeveloped parcels, or multiple parcels that are part of a
condominium, homeowners, or cooperative association (see note
below), before filing a single joint petition. The Property
Appraiser’s Office mailing address is
18500 Murdock Circle, Room 328,
Port Charlotte,
Florida
33948. To
submit your list electronically contact the Property Appraiser’s
Office for an e-mail address (941-743-1495). An electronic list
must be in an Excel spreadsheet with folio numbers only in one
column, and only assessed values in another column. After
receiving the property appraiser’s determination that the
parcels are substantially similar in nature, petitioners are
allowed to file single joint petitions with the Value Adjustment
Board. Complete
Form DR-486 for each group
of parcels, as determined by the Property Appraiser, with a
completed
Form DR-486MU
that has been signed by a Property Appraiser’s Office staff
member. NOTE: Condominiums, cooperative, or homeowners’
associations, as agents, should attach a copy of the Board of
Administration or Directors’ Resolution authorizing this filing.
The Property Appraiser’s Office staff will not file petitions on
a petitioner’s behalf, and the Value Adjustment Board is not
permitted to process a single joint petition for contiguous
undeveloped parcels, or multiple parcels part of an association,
without receipt of the Property Appraiser’s determination.
A filing fee receipt indicating the assigned petition number(s) will
be returned to the petitioner after processing by the Clerk's Office
acknowledging receipt of your petition.
BACK TO TABLE OF CONTENTS
Where to File
-
File online at
https://courts.co.charlotte.fl.us/axiaweb2011/and pay by Mastercard
or Visa credit cards only.
-
Mail petitions with check or money order to the Charlotte County
Clerk of Court, Value Adjustment Board,
18500 Murdock Circle,
Room 416,
Port Charlotte,
Florida
33948.
-
Hand-deliver petitions to the Charlotte County Clerk of Court
Value Adjustment Board,
18500 Murdock Circle,
Room 416,
Port Charlotte,
FL
33948, or
the Charlotte County Clerk of Court Official Records Division at
350 E. Marion Avenue,
Punta Gorda,
FL
33950 and pay by check, money order or
cash. Checks or money orders should be payable to Board of
County Commissioners or BOCC.
BACK TO TABLE OF CONTENTS
Withdrawal Procedures
-
Requests to withdraw petitions must be made in writing to the
VAB Clerk. The Clerk
shall cancel the hearing upon receiving a notice of withdrawal
from the petitioner and there shall be no further proceeding on
the matter.
-
Withdrawals can be mailed or hand delivered to
18500 Murdock Circle,
Port
Charlotte,
FL
33948, or by fax to (941)
623-1043.
-
Click here to Download form
BACK TO TABLE OF CONTENTS
Hearing Information and Reschedule Requests
The VAB clerk will schedule a hearing date and time
for all petitioners. Each petitioner should receive a written notice
of hearing at least 25 calendar days prior to the hearing. The
address used to mail these notices will be the address appearing on
the petition form. It is
the responsibility of the petitioner to notify the VAB Clerk of
address changes.
A petitioner has the right, one single time, to
reschedule a hearing by submitting a written request to the VAB at
least 5 calendar days before the originally scheduled hearing. Reschedule
request received outside of those days much show good cause.
Click here to download reschedule
request form. A petitioner may reschedule their hearing
an unlimited number of times if they show good cause for the
rescheduling.
A petitioner can participate in an evidence
exchange directly with the property appraiser. If the petitioner
chooses to participate in an exchange of evidence, the petitioner
should:
-
Give the property appraiser a list of evidence and copies of
documents that will be presented at the hearing, at least 15
calendar days before the hearing date.It should be noted that the
parties have the right to cross-examine evidence presented at
the hearing.Therefore, in the event a party wishes to rely on
appraisals or other written evidence, the person responsible
for preparing and/or maintaining written evidence must be available
at the hearing for cross-examination.
-
Ask in writing for the property appraiser to provide a list and
summary of the evidence that he or she will present at the
hearing. If the petitioner does not provide evidence information
at least 15 calendar days before the hearing, the property appraiser does
not need to provide this information.
-
If the petitioner makes the request, the property appraiser must
provide the information at least 7 calendar days before the hearing. If
the property appraiser does not provide the information at least
7 calendar days before the hearing, the hearing will be rescheduled.
-
If an agent represents the taxpayer, he or she may ask the
property appraiser for confidential information. Before the
property appraiser can release any confidential information, the
agent must provide a copy of written authorization from you.
Please refer to
Fla. Stat. § 194.011 for more information
regarding evidence exchange.)
-
Unless you are (1) a petitioner who does not appear at a hearing
on a "portability" assessment difference transfer petition in
which the previous homestead is the subject of the petition and
is located in a county other than the county where the new
homestead is located [requirements specific to hearings on such
petitions are set forth in
subsection 12D-9.028(6), F.A.C.]; or (2) a
petitioner who has indicated that he or she does not wish to
appear at the hearing but would like for the special magistrate
to consider evidence submitted by the petitioner, always submit
evidence to the Charlotte County Property Appraiser. Only in these
two type cases will the board clerk present the evidence to the
magistrate.
See subsection 12D-9.025(4)(c).
Hearings before a value adjustment board are not
proceedings that require an attorney or agent. However, depending on
the complexity or value of the property, petitioners may want an
attorney or tax agent to represent them at the hearing.
The hearing schedule should be followed as closely
as possible without interfering with each party’s right to be heard.
If hearings are not started within four hours of the scheduled time,
the petitioner can request to be heard immediately, have the hearing
rescheduled, or withdraw the petition.
After the hearing the special magistrate may make
known what his/her recommendation to the VAB will be or defer
his/her decision until after a more thorough review of the
information. Once the special magistrate finalizes his/her
recommendation, and VAB counsel has reviewed it for legal
sufficiency, the clerk will promptly send that recommendation form
to both parties with notification of the date, time, and place where
the board will meet to review that recommendation and make its final
decision. Parties are not required to attend these meetings;
however, all meetings are open to the public. The value adjustment
board may adopt the magistrate’s recommendations. However, if the
board determines the magistrate failed to consider evidence or made
an incorrect legal determination, the board can make a modified or
different decision than the recommendation.
The clerk of the value adjustment board will notify
both parties in writing of the board’s decision on a petition. The
notice will explain whether any changes were made and will list the
information that the board relied on, as well as the legal reason
for reaching its decision.
Petitioners may file a lawsuit in circuit court if
they do not agree with the decision of the value adjustment board.
See
Fla. Stat. § 194.171(2) and
Fla. Stat. § 194.171(6).
NOTE: If you are considering appealing any
decision of the value adjustment board pursuant to
Fla. Stat. § 194.171, please be advised
that you may need a record of the proceedings before the board and
that preparation of a proper record transcript is the responsibility
of the appealing party.
BACK TO TABLE OF CONTENTS
|